Customers Don’t Care Who’s Responsible

people standing inside city building

Modern businesses have never been more dependent on the actions of organisations over which they have no control. Supply chains span continents. Customer support is outsourced. Payments move through third-party platforms. Technology relies on cloud infrastructure owned by someone else. Very little of the customer experience is now delivered entirely by one organisation.

Internally, those relationships are carefully defined. Contracts allocate responsibility. Service level agreements establish expectations. Escalation processes determine who owns the problem when something goes wrong. Businesses have become highly proficient in distinguishing where their responsibilities begin and end.

To the customer, that definition counts for nothing. The market makes no distinction between a retailer and its delivery partner, or between an online business and its payment processor. As business operations have evolved to be evermore complex and interconnected, customers have, conversely, remained remarkably consistent in how they assign responsibility: holding responsible the organisation they chose to buy from, and not the one that ultimately caused the problem.

The contextual limits of the organisational boundary

Modern businesses, therefore, find themselves judged on outcomes that they don’t completely control, and nowhere is the impact of this clearer than in delivery.

Consider the following scenario. A customer orders a product. The retailer processes that order correctly, and the parcel leaves the warehouse on time. Somewhere between dispatch and delivery, however, something goes wrong. The package is left with an unidentified neighbour, or placed somewhere insecure, or marked as delivered despite never reaching the customer. From that moment on, the internal boundaries which distinguish the retailer, carrier and the logistics provider, effectively, disappear. The customer contacts the retailer because, as they understand it, the agreement they entered into was with the business that accepted their payment. Everything that happens afterwards constitutes part of the same experience.

Research by Citizens Advice illustrates how common these situations have become, with more than a third of UK consumers reporting a problem with their most recent parcel delivery. None of the country’s largest parcel carriers achieved a four-star customer service rating, but the commercial consequences of failure are rarely felt where the failure itself occurred.

Under UK consumer law, responsibility for the resolution of delivery issues rests firmly with the retailer, regardless of which organisation caused the problem. Refunds, replacements and customer communication, the responsibility of the same. With public reviews underpinning modern consumer behaviours, this asymmetrical ‘blame game’ poses a real risk, and makes clear why treating delivery exclusively as a logistics function is no longer sufficient.

Managing trust, not allocating blame

Delivery failures typically trigger a series of internal processes aimed at establishing exactly the who, what, where and why of that failure. A case is opened, evidence collated and carriers liaised with; activities that are entirely appropriate given the legitimate commercial interest every business has in understanding where losses occur and how frequently they happen.

And, while the business works to establish responsibility, the customer is deciding whether the organisation deserves their trust in future.

Research into consumer experience demonstrates consistently that what matters most is how a business responds to a problem, not that a problem occurred in the first place. Most people will adopt a ‘these things happen’ attitude; understanding that complex organisations are, ultimately, unable to eliminate every single mistake. But where organisations rise or fall is in how easy, or difficult, they make the resolution of that mistake.

This changes the nature of the decision facing business leaders. No longer is the question simply how to reduce delivery failures, but rather what degree of authority should an organisation hold to respond when failures inevitably occur. Businesses that empower frontline teams to resolve issues quickly create a very different customer experience from those requiring multiple approvals before replacing a missing parcel or issuing a refund.

The direct financial cost of those actions are easily quantified. The effect on customer confidence much less so.

Competing on Outcomes You Don’t Control

The broader lesson extends well beyond logistics. Organisations now compete through ecosystems rather than ownership. Every business depends upon external partners, technologies and suppliers that influence the customer experience without sitting under direct managerial control. Those dependencies are likely to become more common as businesses continue to specialise.

What differentiates organisations is therefore becoming less about preventing external failure and more about deciding how those failures are experienced by customers, and that requires a subtle shift in thinking.

Customers, after all, judge promises. Whether a delivery problem originated with a carrier, a warehouse, or a third-party contractor has little bearing on whether they return to a business buy again. They won’t remember who caused something to go wrong. They remember who helped put it right. And by approaching logistics through that frame, every business stands to gain.

 

Allan Jeffrey, founder and CEO of premium composite decking company Ultra Decking

About Editor 4283 Articles
Lisa Baker is the Editor of International Business News. As the Owner of Need to See IT Publishing, Lisa is an experienced business and technology journalist and publisher.