Brau Union fights against record fine

Austria’s leading brewer, Brau Union, is contesting a possible record competition fine in court.

 

Competition law rarely captures widespread public attention in Austria. That changes, however, when beer is involved. Proceedings against domestic market leader Brau Union have now moved into their next phase at Vienna’s Palace of Justice. The allegations brought by the Federal Competition Authority (BWB) are significant, with claims that the company breached core principles of antitrust law.

 

As a subsidiary of Heineken, Brau Union holds a dominant position in the Austrian market, with brands including Gösser, Puntigamer, Zipfer, Wieselburger and Schwechater. Of the roughly ten million hectolitres of beer produced annually in Austria, around half originates from Brau Union.

 

The BWB alleges that the company leveraged this market strength to pressure beverage wholesalers into stocking only Brau Union products, removing competing brands from their portfolios. Failure to comply, it is claimed, could result in Brau Union ceasing supply to retailers and instead taking over distribution directly posing an existential threat to some businesses. Such practices, the authority argues, would also raise barriers to entry for rival brewers. Brau Union rejects these accusations.

 

During hearings last June, a former beverage wholesaler described “considerable economic pressure” allegedly exerted by Brau Union. According to the testimony, the company threatened to withdraw delivery routes or supply new customers directly. It was also claimed that a Brau Union sales manager inspected warehouse stock “as a matter of course” to assess the presence of competing beers.

 

In 2019, Brau Union broadened its portfolio to include spirits, wine and soft drinks. “This development has unsettled a number of logistics partners. Competition has intensified, but that alone does not constitute a cartel,” a lawyer representing the company argued.

 

Debate over partners

Early in the third day of proceedings, even the terminology used to describe Brau Union’s business relationships became a point of contention – highlighting the case’s complexity. Should they be referred to as “contractual partners” or “logistics partners”? The judge sought clarification from both sides before agreement was reached. “We do not yet even have a clear market definition; there is still much to address,” the court noted.

 

The first witness, Bart van den Huijsen, Managing Director of Heineken Europe, outlined the group’s structure and its relationship with Brau Union. “Beer brands and operations are highly regional. Local teams are better placed to make decisions than central management in Amsterdam,” he said. “Heineken does not direct Brau Union’s brand strategy, sales or marketing – those decisions sit locally.” While broad financial targets are set and major investments require approval, he emphasised that day-to-day control remains decentralised.

 

The judge pressed further: what if Brau Union chose not to sell Heineken products? “That would be acceptable,” van den Huijsen responded, noting that Heineken accounts for only around two percent of Brau Union’s sales.

 

Question of control

A central issue in the case is whether Heineken exercises “controlling influence” over its Austrian subsidiary. This determination could prove decisive in setting any fine and establishing potential liability for the parent company. Representatives have strongly denied that such control exists.

 

The financial stakes are considerable. In February 2025, Austria’s Supreme Court (OGH) imposed a record €70 million fine on the parent company of Billa, part of the REWE Group. While the current allegations target Brau Union, any penalty could extend to its parent. Under competition law, fines can reach up to ten percent of group turnover, meaning exposure based on Heineken’s global revenues of over €30 billion.

 

The second witness, a senior Brau Union executive responsible for logistics partners and procurement, faced similar scrutiny. Questions focused on budget autonomy and whether directives were issued from Heineken. The responses echoed earlier testimony: while overarching parameters exist, operational decisions are made locally. “Brau Union adapts to customer demand, which is why the product range has expanded. Particularly in hospitality, clients prefer a single supplier. Only a minority of partners opposed this shift,” the witness stated.

 

Tensions rose when BWB lawyers presented an internal email in which a former in-house counsel wrote that Brau Union “is controlled by Heineken.” The witness said he could not recall the context, prompting a dispute between legal teams over what facts were agreed and what remained contested.

 

A gradual rise to dominance

Brau Union’s position at the top of Austria’s beer market was built over time. The company was formed in 1998 through the merger of Österreichische Brau AG and Steirerbrau, before being acquired by Heineken in 2003, a transaction approved by the European Commission. Large-scale mergers are typically subject to regulatory scrutiny and may be blocked or conditioned where necessary.

 

Since 2006, Brau Union has continued to expand through acquisitions. In some cases, authorities identified risks linked to increased market concentration and imposed conditions, for example, during the purchase of the Association of Carinthian Breweries in 2014 and the acquisition of Vorarlberg-based Fohrenburg in 2020.

 

While Brau Union’s market dominance is not in dispute, the court must now determine whether that position has been abused. All parties acknowledge that substantial work remains before a conclusion can be reached.

 

From the BWB’s perspective, the case centres on whether Brau Union sought to limit market access for competing brewers while squeezing independent beverage wholesalers out of the market.