Big Election in Belgium largely unnoticed by their EU Neighbours – yet it could impact Belgium’s Long Term Future

Written by Martin Banks

The second big election in Belgium this has come and gone with little or no fanfare outside of the small Benelux country.

But the local elections at the weekend, which followed close on the heels of national and Euro elections earlier in the year, sparked huge interest within the country… with results in at least one constituency once again triggering some debate about the long term future of Belgium.

 

Many predictions of a political upheaval did not really come to pass.

The overall result was a bit of a hotchpotch, with gains for some, losses for others but no massive shocks. Arguably, the Greens Ecolo and Groen and the centrist party DéFI were the biggest losers. The centre-right parties MR and Les Engagés made significant gains while the Belgian Workers Party (PTB-PVDA) also gained a foothold in a few municipalities.

 

The biggest shock came in the East Flanders municipality of Ninove where the “Forza Ninove” list of Vlaams Belang (it has long advocated the break up of Belgium and independence for Flanders) obtained an absolute majority of seats with 47.4%: 18 out of 35, enough to be able to take over the mayoralty without a partner – a first for the far-right in Belgium.

For years there has been an unwritten political “understanding” in Belgium which is called “cordon sanitaire”.

 

This is a system which has been used since 1989 by the traditional parties to isolate and exclude the extreme right-wing Vlaams Blok. All parties decided to support the cordon to keep the extreme right out of the government.

However, the results in Ninove have sent minor shockwaves through the political establishment in the country and again reignited debate in some quarters about the possibility of Flanders “going it alone” and declaring independence.

It is an issue which, as with Scotland and its continued part of the UK, seems to refuse to go away. It is still highly unlikely Belgium will split but the mere re-emergence of such talk will be cause of concern to some, including at EU level.

One thing that some voters, at least, in Belgium seem to have in common with just about everywhere else is growing apathy towards politics.

Sunday’s local elections were the first election where voting was not compulsory in Flanders, and many voters there did not show up. The participation rate is thought to be around 63%.

Voting in Belgium is, in theory, compulsory and you run the risk of a fine if you fail to show up to vote. But, in practice, it is well known that enforcement by the authorities of this rule is, at best, inconsistent.

For a country the size and population of Belgium, the fiendishly convoluted web that passes for a political system leaves many outsiders totally lost for words.

 

Which is more than can be said for the endless number of people – politicians, pundits, media and others – who fill the TV screens,newsprint and social media with their opinions whenever an election comes around.

One such occasion was this weekend and Belgium’s local elections.

 

It is worth remembering that this was the second big election in Belgium this year alone, following on from national and European elections earlier in 2024.

In the run up to the elections on Sunday (13 October) towns the length and breadth of the country were taken over by the sight of hundreds and hundreds of posters featuring the many candidates standing in that particular commune or municipality.

 

If you’d just landed from another planet and had no idea what was going on in Belgium on 13 October it wouldn’t be long before you did, such is the extent to which the many political parties go to get their candidates’ faces imprinted on the public psyche.

 

It is probably necessary, first,to emphasise that these “local” elections bear little or no resemblance to, say, the equivalent in the UK (or many other countries come to that).

The mayor, or burgomaster to give him/her their correct title, in a local Belgian town (even the smallest) really does possess not insignificant powers.

 

These include being in charge of the local police force, including the budget.

But the said competences extend over a whole host of other important areas that directly impact on everyday life.

Compared to countries like the UK and France, municipalities have much more clout in Belgium and decide on matters from land planning, public roads, cleanliness, public order and economic development to social aid and the municipal schools in their territory.

This is due, of course, to the federal nature of the Belgian political system whereby even a small village/hamlet gets to elect local representatives who, in turn, enjoy the sort of powers their equivalent in the UK can only dream of.

This “bottom up” approach has, in the main, been resisted for a long time in places like the UK but is a fundamental of how Belgium works and, it could be argued, is a vital component in the nation’s cohesiveness.

 

Belgium, of course, is not alone in employing a federal system to run its affairs.

 

In Switzerland, the same applies with the electorate having their say on many local, regional and national decisions. Indeed (unlike in Belgium), every year, the Swiss decide in hundreds of referendums on issues that directly affect citizens.

From a young age, Belgians are taught that, yes, voting really does matter and that the local level of Belgian politics has a big impact on streets, everyday lives and vital services. The message is that if you vote, you play a big role in choosing leaders and policies. This is almost part of Belgium’s DNA.

 

By casting a vote for a political party, voters decide on many of the things affecting day-to-day goings-on in neighbourhoods. The general idea is also that if you are voting for someone who is local (usually, the candidates work and live locally) – and who has certain powers at his/her disposal – you are more likely to feel “engaged” with the political process.

 

This, it could be argued of course, is no bad thing at a time when public engagement with politics and politicians has fallen to such a low ebb.

 

In Belgium at the weekend, it was not just all local communes holding elections. On the same day voters also elected representatives for provincial councils, the bodies responsible for tourism, culture and schools.

 

In the multi layered tapestry that is Belgian politics provincial councils are yet another tier of government.

In fact, Belgium has not only five fully fledged governments – four regional and one federal – throughout Brussels, Wallonia, Flanders and its small German-speaking region in the east – but also no less than 31,806 politicians and an army of employees sustaining its offices and cabinets.

England, by comparison, has 17,000 local councillors.  In Brussels alone, there were some 3,809 candidates on 124 lists for Sunday’s local elections.

There are French or Dutch language lists and you are asked to choose between a party list vote or a preferential vote. Popular candidates who may be as low as 12 on a list can be voted into power.

 

After the election, a council (commune) made up of the mayor and councillors is formed. The mayor is the equivalent of the prime minister and the councillors are the equivalent of the government ministers, says Delwit, comparing the local and the federal level.

 

Belgium has, since it became a federal system way back in 1970, had layers of government. They are at just about every level, from the national, municipal,regional, provincial and communal. The system invariably leaves the country facing months (sometimes years) of painfully slow negotiations in order to find a working coalition to run the place).

 

Briton Bryn Watkins is a long term resident in Belgium and close observer of its electoral system. He told this website: “Municipalities in Belgium are a lot more independent than their equivalents in most other countries. They can make their own policies or modify the implementation of regional/federal policies in all sorts of areas where they are competent: streets and mobility, cleanliness and security etc. The people and parties we elect at municipal level make decisions that really change our daily lives.”

 

He adds, “Municipalities in Belgium manage and deliver more services than their equivalents in most other countries: Registration of foreigners and applying for nationality, (some) schools, planning permits, social services and assistance, etc. The people and parties we elect at municipal level directly manage the local civil servants who deliver most of the public administration that we interact with as residents of Belgium.”

 

Looking to the future, a new study concludes that the system in Belgium really is just too complex to remain sustainable and needs changing.

The study, by UCLouvain university and LIDAM (Leuven Institute of Data Analysis and Monitoring), cites the “weight, complexity and dysfunction of our political institutions.”

It concludes: “This multiplication of power levels and political structures entails significant costs and chronic inaction.”

 

—

Image: Freepik

 

About Editor 4283 Articles
Lisa Baker is the Editor of International Business News. As the Owner of Need to See IT Publishing, Lisa is an experienced business and technology journalist and publisher.